There's nothing quite like gathering around a fire pit on a cool evening — but before you buy, there's one big decision to make: wood burning or gas? Both bring warmth and ambiance to your outdoor space, but they suit very different lifestyles. Here's how to figure out which one is right for you.
The Case for Wood Burning Fire Pits
Wood burning fire pits deliver the classic campfire experience: crackling logs, dancing flames, and that unmistakable smoky scent. For a lot of homeowners, that sensory experience is the whole point of having a fire pit in the first place.
Pros:
- Authentic ambiance. The sound, smell, and higher flame height of a wood fire is hard to replicate.
- Lower upfront cost. Wood burning fire pits are typically less expensive than their gas counterparts, since there's no burner system or gas line involved.
- No utility hookup required. You don't need a gas line or propane tank — just wood and a lighter.
- More heat output. Wood fires often burn hotter, which is great for colder climates or larger gatherings.
Cons:
- More maintenance. Ash cleanup after every use, plus regular cleaning to prevent buildup.
- Smoke. Depending on wind direction, smoke can be a nuisance for you and your neighbors.
- Less control. You can't adjust the flame with the turn of a knob, and putting it out takes longer.
- Wood storage. You'll need a dry, accessible place to store firewood.
If you love the ritual of building a fire and don't mind the extra upkeep, a wood burning fire pit is hard to beat for pure atmosphere.
The Case for Gas Fire Pits
Gas fire pits — whether powered by natural gas or propane — have surged in popularity for a simple reason: convenience. Flip a switch, and you've got instant fire.
Pros:
- Instant on/off. No fire-building skills required, and no waiting for embers to die down before heading inside.
- No smoke or ash. Cleaner burning means no soot on your patio furniture and no smoke drifting into the house.
- Consistent flame. Many gas fire pits let you adjust flame height, giving you more control over ambiance and heat.
- Lower long-term maintenance. No wood to buy, store, or clean up.
Cons:
- Higher upfront cost. Between the unit itself and potential gas line installation, gas fire pits typically cost more to get started.
- Installation considerations. Natural gas models may require professional installation to connect to your home's gas line, while propane models need tank refills.
- Less "campfire" feel. Gas flames are beautiful, but purists sometimes miss the crackle and higher flames of real wood.
For homeowners who want a low-maintenance, ready-in-seconds fire pit experience — especially for frequent entertaining — gas is usually the better fit.
Which One Fits Your Lifestyle?
Ask yourself a few quick questions:
- How often will you use it? Frequent use favors gas for the convenience factor.
- Do you enjoy the process of building a fire, or just the result? If it's the ritual you love, go wood. If you just want the ambiance without the effort, go gas.
- What's your climate like? Colder regions often lean toward wood burning for the extra heat output.
- Do you have easy access to a gas line, or are you comfortable using propane tanks? This can make gas installation simpler or more complex depending on your setup.
- How much maintenance are you willing to take on? Wood means regular ash cleanup; gas means occasional burner checks.
Explore Fire Pits at Lux Outdoor Fireplaces
Whichever direction you lean, we carry both styles from trusted brands. Browse our Fire Pit Art collection for premium wood burning and gas fire pit sculptures, or check out Sierra Flame for versatile gas fire pit options built for everyday entertaining.
FAQ
Can I convert a wood burning fire pit to gas? It's possible with the right conversion kit, but it's usually more cost-effective to choose the fuel type you want from the start.
Are gas fire pits safe to use on a wood deck? Many gas fire pits are deck-safe due to lower heat output at the base, but always check the manufacturer's clearance requirements and consider a heat-resistant pad.
Do wood burning fire pits need a chimney or spark screen? A spark screen is highly recommended to contain embers, especially in dry climates or near landscaping.
Which option adds more resale value to my home? Built-in gas fire pits with a permanent gas line tend to be viewed as a larger home improvement investment, while portable wood burning pits are seen as more of a lifestyle accessory.
Have questions about which fire pit fits your space? Contact us or call (877) 335-2178 — we're happy to help you find the right fit.
